struck down section 3 of the Defense of Marriage Act (DOMA) and dismissed an appeal of California’s Proposition 8 on grounds of standing. But what does this mean? What are the implications of the court decisions? Here’s the good, the bad and the ugly from today’s rulings:
The court did not claim to have discovered a fundamental “right” to
marry. If it had done so, it could have imposed a redefinition of
marriage on the entire country, forcing widespread recognition of “gay
marriage.” Instead, the court chose to issue a more limited ruling,
saying in its DOMA decision that the states are free to define marriage
as they see fit, but if they choose to
recognize same-sex “marriage,” the federal government must acknowledge
these “marriages” alongside the marriages of one man and one woman.
States are still free to hold a view of marriage as one man, one woman
if they choose to do so. This is a silver lining on a court decision
that could have been absolutely devastating.
Overturning DOMA means that the federal government will recognize “gay
marriage” in the states that allow it. This will affect more than 1,000
regulations and legal provisions, and could have a sweeping impact on
both the legal and cultural understanding of what marriage is. And by
dismissing Prop 8, the court is allowing a lower ruling to stand, paving
the way for “gay marriage” in California. In addition, since the
federal government must acknowledge all state-recognized marriages,
there will be increased pressure on the states to redefine marriage.
The majority opinion in DOMA makes the claim that those who
support the law do so in order to “disparage,” “injure,” “degrade,”
“demean” and “humiliate” gay individuals. This is very bad news for
those who defend marriage not out of animus or hatred but because they
believe that marriage is rooted in divine and natural law and is not
ours to redefine. As Justice Scalia explained in a scathing dissent, the
court today has declared those who oppose a redefinition of marriage to
be “enemies of the human race.” Supporters of marriage as it has been
understood by virtually every society throughout human history need to
be prepared for social persecution, since even the nation’s high court
now assumes that defending marriage is based on hatred and bigotry
rather than a natural understanding of the sacred purpose of human
sexuality. Defenders of marriage may find that their rights to voice
their beliefs and live according to them are quickly eroding after this
Popular This Week
The second Eucharistic miracle of Siena has roots in the 13th century when special services and festivities were introduced in honor o...
Did you know that the bodies of some Saints did not Decay? Some in parts while others are total... The Incorruptibles, a great Mystery! ...
Article 1: I believe in God, the Father Almighty, Creator of heaven and earth. This affirms that God exists, that he's a Triu...
Every time we hear a truth, like Mary's Assumption for instance, some immediately ask "Where is it in the bible" ? It i...
Follow on Google+
abortion (1) Anglican (1) Annunciation (1) Apocrypha (1) Apostles (1) Assumption (2) Benedict XVI (12) Black Mass (1) Blessed Trinity (1) Canonization (2) Catholic (7) Catholic Apologetics (8) Catholic Humor (2) Christmas (1) Confession (1) Curia (1) Curia Reform (1) Dea (1) Devil (2) Didache (1) Dogma (1) Encyclical (1) Eucharist (1) Eucharistic Miracles (1) Excommunication (1) Fear (1) Forgiveness (2) Freedom (1) Gaudete (1) Gay Marriage (1) heresy (1) Holy Spirit (1) Homosexual (1) Immaculate Conception (1) Jesus (2) John Paul II (3) John XXIII (1) Love (3) Mary (1) mass (1) Persecuted Church (1) Poems (2) Pontifex (1) Pope (2) Pope Francis (25) Pope Pius XII. (1) Prayer (1) Preaching (1) Priest (4) Prophesy (1) Purgatory (1) Roman Parish (1) Sacrament (1) Satanic Mass (1) sermon (1) Sex (1) Sin (2) Superstition (1) Virgin Mary (2) Vision (1) Witches (1)
- December (6)
- November (4)
- Pope Francis: the Holy Spirit renews our lives
- Encyclical Letter Lumen Fidei of the Supreme Ponti...
- Pope Francis signs canonization decrees for John X...
- Benedict XVI joins Pope Francis in consecrating Va...
- Understanding the ‘gay marriage’ rulings
- Works of mercy caress, bind Christ's wounds, Pope ...
- Pennsylvania bishop dies, age 85
- Pope Francis gives church hundreds of new saints
- Pope gets soaked as he braves rain to greet crowds...
- John Paul II in final stretch toward becoming a sa...
- June (6)
- May (20)
- April (15)
©2013 Catholic and Proud. Powered by Blogger.